Define What Matters

Clarity comes before commitment. Once the picture is clear, the question is what matters, and Define What Matters is the practice of answering it out loud.

Why This Matters

A team watches what its leader protects under pressure. That is how the team learns what matters: not from the values statement, but from the tradeoffs the leader makes when money is tight and priorities compete.

When a leader is unclear on their own priorities, the ambiguity spreads. People hedge. They wait for a signal. They choose what looks safe over what moves the mission. Clarity at the top becomes clarity throughout.

Leaders who worked this practice in Think Tank sessions reported the same discovery: a gap between the values they stated and the values they defended, which they had not seen before. One city manager said: “I thought transparency was our priority. Then I realized we protect efficiency over openness every single time.”

Stated values are what an organization says matters. Defended values are what it protects when protecting them costs something. The gap between the two is where the work is.

The Core Challenge

Most organizations have a values statement. Fewer have values that guide a decision when the decision costs something. The gap between the statement and the decisions shows where the practice starts.

Define What Matters is the practice of getting clear on what the organization will protect when protecting it creates friction. The answer is rarely the line on the website or the sentence in the strategic plan. It is whatever survived the last hard week.

What This Practice Looks Like

The Cost Test

For each stated value, the leader asks: “When has protecting this value cost us something?” A value with no instance to point to is an aspiration rather than an operating rule. That is useful information, and the leader now knows which values are which.

Values Under Pressure

When the budget gets tight, what survives? When the timeline compresses, what gets protected? When political pressure builds, what does the leadership team refuse to give up? The answers are the organization’s real priorities, and they may differ from the ones the team would prefer to believe in.

The Why Behind the What

Simon Sinek’s line applies: people do not buy what an organization does, they buy why it does it. A team needs the purpose behind each priority, not only the priority. When people understand why something matters, they make aligned decisions without waiting for guidance.

Diagnostic Questions

Five questions that show the gap between stated and defended values:

Can I name three values the organization defended when it cost something?
Would my direct reports give the same answer to “what matters most here”?
When did the leadership team last say no to something good to protect something better?
Can the team explain why the priorities are the priorities?
What tradeoffs has the organization made this year, and what do they show about its real values?

One conversation to try this week: Ask a trusted colleague: “If you had to describe what we actually prioritize here, based on what we do, not what we say, what would you say?” Then listen without correcting. The distance between their answer and the intended priorities is the distance this practice closes.

The Connection Forward

Define What Matters produces the clarity that Make It Real turns into systems. A system that protects a priority needs the priority named first.

The practice often sends a leader back to Face the Truth, because examining values shows how those values play out in the organization, and some of that is new information. That is the method working. This week: run the cost test on one stated value with the leadership team, and write the answer where the team can see it.

Where is the pressure showing up?

The four practices work together. One of these situations may offer a useful place to begin.

People are acting from different versions of what is happening. Begin with Face the Truth
A priority is understood, but follow-through still depends on reminders or workarounds. Begin with Make It Real
Progress is visible, but older habits or routines are beginning to return. Begin with Reinforce the Change

The work rarely stays inside one practice. Adaptive leaders draw on all four as a system, starting where the pressure is clearest and returning as conditions change.

What Stalls AI Adoption in Local Government?

What a Federal AI Privacy Ruling Means for Local Government

What Points Managers at the Wrong Problem?